Probate or notary? Two ways the world settles an estate
In London a court validates the will; in Paris a notary steers the file. Understanding which system you live in — and where your assets are — changes how you should prepare.

Broadly, common-law countries (such as England and Wales, most US states, Australia) settle estates through probate: a court validates the will and grants authority to an executor, who administers the estate. Civil-law countries (such as France, Germany, Spain, Italy) typically rely on notaries and rules that apply automatically, including forced heirship. The two systems differ in who is in charge, how long it takes, how public it is and how much freedom you have to choose your heirs.
- Common law: court + executor + broad testamentary freedom. Civil law: notary + statutory heirs + protected shares.
- Probate can make parts of the process public; notarial systems are generally more private.
- Where your assets are located may matter as much as where you live.
- In both systems, the biggest delay is usually the same: finding the assets and the documents.
Two families, two countries, the same sad event. In England, the executor applies for a grant of probate and becomes the person banks deal with. In France, the family calls the notary, who drafts the act establishing the heirs and coordinates almost everything. Same goal, different machinery.
The two families of legal systems
| Common law (probate) | Civil law (notarial) | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical countries | England & Wales, Ireland, most US states, Canada (outside Quebec), Australia, Singapore | France, Belgium, Germany, Spain, Italy, Switzerland, Quebec, much of Latin America |
| Who leads | Executor (named in the will) or court-appointed administrator | Notary, with heirs often stepping in directly |
| Role of the court | Central: validates the will and grants authority | Limited: mainly for disputes or special cases |
| Freedom to choose heirs | Broad, with family-provision claims in some places | Restricted by forced heirship rules |
| Privacy | Wills admitted to probate can become public records in some jurisdictions | Generally private |
| Tools | Trusts, joint tenancy, beneficiary designations | Marriage contracts, gifts, usufruct, life insurance |
Every country has its own variants — Scotland, Louisiana, Quebec and many others mix traditions. Use this as a map, not as legal advice.
Why it matters for your preparation
In a probate system
- Choose your executor carefully: they will do real work.
- Think about which assets can pass outside probate (beneficiary designations, joint accounts, trusts) — and check they are consistent with your will.
- Expect that parts of the will could become public in some jurisdictions; keep sensitive details elsewhere.
In a notarial system
- Know that part of your estate may be reserved for your children by law (see Forced heirship: why you can’t always leave everything to whoever you want).
- Tell your notary about all your assets — including foreign and digital ones they cannot discover on their own.
- Use the tools of your system: marriage regime, gifts during lifetime, life insurance.
The common bottleneck
Whichever system applies, the slowest part is rarely the law. It is discovery: finding every account, contract and document. Executors and notaries are skilled at legal procedure; they are not detectives. As our own FAQ puts it, searching for assets is not their specialty — they may be unable to help if your family doesn't know an asset exists.

Ready for either system
OSTREON is jurisdiction-neutral: it organises what any executor or notary needs — a complete list of assets with institution, country and value, the supporting documents, and your professional's contact details. Your beneficiaries receive it automatically, and can hand it straight to the executor or notary.
With separate EU and US instances, your data stays under the privacy law of your region.
Start your free month →If you live in one system and own assets in another, read Living abroad? How the EU Succession Regulation decides which law applies to your estate and Assets in three countries: a cross-border inheritance playbook.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between probate and a notarial succession?
Probate is a court-supervised process used in common-law countries, led by an executor or administrator. In civil-law countries, a notary usually coordinates the succession, and statutory rules such as forced heirship apply.
Do I need probate if I live in France?
France uses a notarial system rather than probate. However, if you own assets in a common-law country, a probate-type procedure may be needed there.
Is a will public?
It depends on the jurisdiction. In some common-law systems, wills admitted to probate can become public records; notarial systems are generally more private. Never put passwords or secrets in a will.
What slows down estate settlement the most?
In both systems, discovering all assets and gathering documents is usually the biggest bottleneck — which is why an up-to-date asset record helps so much.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules differ by country and change over time — check with a qualified notary, lawyer or adviser for your situation.



